Comparison
TodoCity vs Todoist: a private Todoist alternative for Mac
TodoCity is a private, Mac-only alternative to Todoist. Where Todoist keeps your tasks in its cloud behind an account, TodoCity keeps them on your Mac, works offline and uses on-device AI to turn copied text into dated tasks. Todoist is the better pick if you need apps on every platform or shared projects with a team. TodoCity can import your Todoist projects, sections, tasks and completed tasks.
At a glance
| Feature | TodoCity | Todoist |
|---|---|---|
| Price | Free, open source (MIT) | Free plan, paid plans for more |
| Platforms | Mac | Web, Mac, Windows, iPhone, Android and more |
| Where tasks live | On your Mac | Todoist's servers |
| Account | None | Required |
| Works offline | Fully | Partly |
| AI | On your Mac, works offline | Cloud features |
| AI apps and your tasks (MCP) | Built in, on your Mac: add-only with your OK, or full access | Official MCP server in the cloud, and agents can read and change your tasks |
| Background AI agent | Yes: checks new email on a schedule and sends the to-dos for review | No, forward each email yourself |
| Turn copied text into a task | ⌘C twice, in any app | Browser extensions, email forwarding, share sheet |
| Sharing with others | No | Yes, shared projects |
| Works with the other | Two-way sync with Todoist, or import (API token or CSV) | No |
Why people switch
- Privacy: no account and no cloud copy of your tasks.
- Capture from any app with ⌘C twice, read by AI on your Mac.
- Planning on the clock: Today with its hours and a week calendar beside your events.
- A work Mac that can't use cloud apps can still sync with your personal Mac, end-to-end encrypted.
- A calmer kind of motivation: your city lights up as you finish things, with no karma points or streaks.
AI agents, on your terms
Both apps work with AI assistants over MCP, but in opposite ways. Todoist's MCP server lives in the cloud and lets an agent read and change your account. TodoCity's runs on your Mac and starts add-only: Claude, Cursor, VS Code and other AI apps can add tasks, can't see a thing, and every task waits for your OK. Turn on Full access and they can read and change your list too, still through your Mac.
TodoCity can also suggest tasks on its own: turn on Watch and it spots requests and promises in the app in front of you, read by the open model on your Mac or by an agent you choose. Every suggestion waits for your OK.
What carries over
| Todoist | TodoCity |
|---|---|
| Project (and sub-projects) | Project |
| Inbox | Tasks with no project |
| Section | Section |
| Sub-tasks | Sub-tasks |
| Labels | #tags |
| Priority 1–3 | Priority P1–P3 |
| Description and comments | Notes |
| Recurring dates | Repeats (daily, weekdays, weekly, every 2 weeks, monthly, yearly) |
| Completed tasks | Done tasks: lit windows in your city |
Who should pick which
- Pick TodoCity if your tasks are personal, you work on a Mac, and you'd rather they never leave it.
- Pick Todoist if you need Windows, Android or the web, or share projects with other people.
Questions
How do I move from Todoist to TodoCity?
In TodoCity, open Settings → Connectors → Todoist and paste your Todoist API token (Todoist → Settings → Integrations → Developer). With Keep in sync on, TodoCity and Todoist stay in sync both ways, so you can keep Todoist on your phone. Or export projects as CSV files.